Dark Mirror bak-10 Read online

  ‘Well, she believes that Marion’s death has something to do with the work she was doing for her thesis.’

  ‘Did she explain how? It doesn’t seem very likely, surely?’

  ‘Aye, that was my feeling too, and she didn’t really explain, but I went along with it, because I wanted to learn more about Marion’s life down here. And to tell you the truth, I’ve been finding it all very interesting.’

  ‘What have you been doing?’

  ‘We’ve been at the British Library, following the trail of Marion’s book requests. Tina has Marion’s reader’s card, and seems to be able to access her records.’

  Kathy wondered where she’d got that from.

  ‘When we get the books we work together, reading, looking for references that might mean something. She has a list of key words.’

  He sounded so enthusiastic that she wondered if he’d been looking for an excuse not to go back home. Well, Kathy thought, at least it’ll keep them both out of trouble. She couldn’t imagine Keith Rafferty having much problem with what they were doing. ‘And did you find anything?’

  ‘We only started today, and to be perfectly honest I can’t see where it will lead, but at least it gives me a chance to chat to her about Marion.’ He paused, and his voice took on a more loaded tone. Kathy thought the Scottish word for it would have been canny. ‘She mentioned that you had shown her Marion’s new home, Inspector. Very nice, she said, in a pricey part of town. I wondered how she could have afforded it.’

  ‘We’ve been wondering the same thing, Donald. Apparently the estate agent believed she had come into an inheritance, from a Scottish relative with business interests in Switzerland.

  ‘Switzerland!’ Fotheringham snorted. ‘The only Swiss interest in the family that I’m aware of is Bessie’s cuckoo clock. I’ll check with Bessie when I call her tonight, but I hadn’t heard of a death in the family lately, and if there had been I’d be very surprised if there was any money involved.’

  •

  Kathy caught the tube back to Finchley Central and walked through darkened suburban streets towards her home. There had been rain, and water dripped from branches overhanging the pavement and hissed beneath the tyres of passing cars. She hesitated as her block came into view, scanning the shadows for the shape of a human figure. When she reached the light of the front door to the lobby, she checked back over her shoulder before turning her key in the lock. There was a single envelope waiting in her scrubbed-out mailbox, with Jock’s handwritten scrawl of her name on the front. Inside were sets of keys, a note from the locksmith explaining what they’d done, and a bill.

  She caught herself holding her breath as she stood in the lift waiting for the doors to close, as if half expecting someone to leap in at the last moment. The same when the doors slid open at her floor. There were two new locks on her door, and she fiddled with the keys, feeling like a gaoler. She went into the silent flat, checking it quickly, then took off her clothes and had a shower.

  Afterwards, feeling a little easier, she boiled some pasta and added a jar of sauce from the fridge.

  Brock was protecting her, she told herself, not from Rafferty but from herself. He was still convinced that she was identifying with Marion in a way that was disturbing her judgement. But their stories weren’t the same. Unlike Marion, whose early life had been disrupted, poverty-stricken and possibly abused, she had grown up in a perfectly happy, protected middle-class family in the London suburbs. It was only at the age of twelve that things had veered dramatically off-course. On a hot summer’s afternoon her father, that proud, rather distant and intimidating figure, had driven his car into the support structure of a bridge on the M1. The ensuing investigation revealed that he had not only corruptly abused his civil service position to aid property developers, but had also invested everything the family owned in a failed business deal. Abruptly Kathy’s childhood, seen now as a golden haze of lost innocence, was over. Her mother, affectionate but weak, was unable to cope. Together they moved up to Sheffield to live with Aunt Mary and Uncle Tom by the steelworks in Attercliffe.

  It was the failing mother/rescuing aunt part that had struck Brock, Kathy supposed, that and her escaping back to London at the first opportunity. But otherwise their stories were quite different. Her own mother had barely survived the move and died soon after, and her own school career in Sheffield had been less than glorious, her escape route the police force rather than university.

  All the same… She stared at Marion’s picture on the wall. Perhaps the differences between them made it impossible for Kathy to get inside that other mind. The academic stuff, for instance, the historical research that Tina seemed to think so important, what chance did Kathy have of finding her way through that? Tina must have da Silva in mind, she thought. Could da Silva, the pompous, opinionated tutor with whom Marion had apparently quarrelled, have been her lover?

  Kathy had added a few more trophies to her wall alongside the images from the previous night. A picture of the unknown Victorian woman was there now, taken from the SOCO pictures, and another of Montpellier cistus, though what these images meant, and how they were related, wasn’t clear to her.

  But Donald Fotheringham had mentioned Tina’s list of key words, and it occurred to her that it might help her too to navigate Marion’s mind. She searched through a pile of papers on her table and found it again, a list of seventeen items, the first ten of which were people’s names. Some of the names were up there on the enlarged photograph of Marion’s pinboard, and with the help of Tony da Silva’s biography of Rossetti, Kathy was able to work up a few notes on their stories and relationships to the central figure of Rossetti.

  Lizzie Siddal was his sickly wife, the model for Millais’ Ophelia ; Rossetti married her in 1860 after a protracted relationship when it appeared that she was on the point of death. She had survived another couple of years before taking the fatal dose of laudanum.

  Janey Morris, nee Burden, the wife of William Morris, was the great love of Rossetti’s life, with whom he was infatuated for about twenty years until they broke off their affair in 1877. She was also a model for the Pre-Raphaelites, painted over a hundred times by Rossetti.

  Fanny Cornforth was another of Rossetti’s models and his mistress, and he was reputed to have also had a ‘flirtation’ with Annie Miller, who posed for Holman Hunt’s painting The Awakening Conscience. This painting, reproduced in da Silva’s book, showed Annie as a Victorian woman caught rising from the lap of a gentleman visitor in a living room furnished in plush Victorian style, rather, Kathy thought, like Marion’s own back room. Most striking was a large mirror on the wall behind the guilty couple, reflecting their awkward pose from behind. It had a gilt frame, very similar to the one in Marion’s bedroom, almost as if she’d composed her own interior to reflect Holman Hunt’s scene of adulterous temptation.

  All of these names could be found on Marion’s pinboard, connected by a web of scarlet threads, as well as many others: Edward Burne-Jones linked with Georgiana Burne-Jones as well as Maria Zambaco; Holman Hunt with Annie Miller and also Fanny Waugh and Edith Waugh. Kathy began to see the board as a map of the complicated amorous entanglements of the group-some legitimate, others secret and adulterous.

  But the other names on Tina’s checklist, the Wardles, Smiths and Haverlock, were not on Marion’s pinboard, although small images of all three of the paintings on the list were there.

  Kathy referred again to the extensive index at the back of da Silva’s book and found Wardle, George. She turned to the reference and read: George Wardle was associated with William Morris between 1865 and 1889, becoming manager of Morris and Company and acting as a steadying influence on Morris’s business ventures. He and his wife Lena Wardle became part of the wider Pre-Raphaelite circle following their marriage in 1861, the year in which Morris, Marshall, Faulkner and Company was founded. Lena was notorious as the Scottish poisoner Madeleine Smith, who came to London after her acquittal in Glasgow for the murder of Pierre Em
ile L’Angelier in 1858. Her history was well known within the Pre-Raphaelite circle; at the time of her trial, Rossetti, upon seeing her portrait in a newspaper, declared that she would never be hanged as she was a stunner, their favourite term of approbation for an attractive young woman, potentially a model. Later, when she had moved to London and married Wardle, Rossetti wrote a satirical short play for the private amusement of Jane Morris, in which Lena Wardle poisons William Morris in order for her husband George to acquire the company.

  Kathy stared at the words the Scottish poisoner, and had a feeling that she had discovered the identity of the unnamed woman on Marion’s board. A few minutes on the internet confirmed it. There were dozens of references to Madeleine Smith on the web, providing various photographs and drawings that had been made of her and recounting her story.

  Madeleine Smith first met Emile L’Angelier in 1855 through a mutual friend in Glasgow. Madeleine was an attractive twenty-year-old, the granddaughter of one of Glasgow’s best-known architects. Emile was twelve years older, a French Channel Islander who had been travelling in Scotland on the lookout for an advantageous marriage to a well-connected young woman. He had already spent some time cultivating a lady in Fife, without success. He now focused on Madeleine, who was swept off her feet, entering into a secret affair with him which lasted for eighteen months. Eventually Madeleine began to cool. Realising that her family would never agree to a match with Emile, and being now pursued by a much more eligible man, she told Emile that she wanted to end the relationship, and asked for the return of the hundreds of love letters she had given him. He refused and said that he would never allow her to marry another man. Under Scottish law at that time, a woman who had sexual intercourse with a man, and who stated her intention to marry him, both of which Madeleine had confirmed in her letters, was technically regarded as already his wife. Madeleine begged him to be reasonable, and during the course of March 1857 they continued to have nocturnal meetings at the window of her house, during which she gave him cups of coffee and cocoa. He complained several times to his landlady of feeling ill after these meetings, and following their final meeting on the twenty-third of March he collapsed and died. The cause of death was established as arsenic poisoning. Madeleine was found to have bought several batches of the poison, and she was arrested and brought to trial.

  The trial of Madeleine Smith was one of the great murder trials of Victorian Britain, Kathy learned, and continued to provoke debate. Some saw her as a rich, promiscuous psychopath, others as the victim of a ruthless predator. Her sympathisers speculated that Emile, when he finally realised that he was going to lose Madeleine as he had the lady in Fife, committed suicide by taking arsenic, leaving a trail of diary notes and conversations with his landlady to implicate his lover. Others suggested that he had indeed poisoned himself, but never intended death, hoping instead to move Madeleine to change her mind. They pointed to the fact that Madeleine was quite open about buying the poison, which was not uncommon in those days, and that Emile’s first diary entry alleging poisoning predated her earliest purchase.

  Madeleine was defended by a brilliant and eloquent advocate, who nevertheless privately believed her guilty. The jury decided otherwise, bringing down the peculiar Scottish verdict of Not Proven, which one wit described as meaning ‘Not guilty, but don’t do it again’.

  Well, it had happened again, or something rather similar. Kathy sat back, looking over the notes she’d made. The tale resonated so strikingly with Marion’s own that it was impossible to ignore, but what did it mean? That Marion had become obsessed by the Victorian woman and killed herself in some kind of macabre parody of Madeleine’s story? Or that someone else had killed Marion, in such a way that she would understand exactly what was happening to her? The thought was chilling: a coded murder that only Marion would have been able to interpret.

  The buzzer of Kathy’s entry-phone sounded, the sudden noise making her jump.

  ‘Hello?’

  ‘Hi, Kathy?’ She thought she recognised the voice through the electric crackle, and her heart gave a little thump. ‘It’s me-Guy. Hi. I’ve got something for you. Is this a bad time?’

  ‘No, hello, Guy. You want to come up?’

  ‘If that’s okay. Twelfth floor?’

  ‘That’s it.’ She pressed the button to unlock the front door, cleared the remains of her dinner and went out to the lobby to meet him.

  The lift sighed to a stop and he stepped through the doors with a big grin, clutching a bunch of daffodils. His cheek felt cool, his coat damp from a light drizzle.

  ‘Come in.’

  ‘Are you okay? I’ve been worrying about you, after that cat. Any developments?’

  She didn’t tell him about the head on her pillow, and changed the subject. ‘Lovely flowers!’

  ‘I noticed you didn’t have any in your flat. Maybe you don’t like them?’

  ‘I love them. I’m just too lazy to buy any. Let me put them in water. Take off your coat and help yourself to a glass of wine. Have you eaten?’

  ‘I grabbed a sandwich at work. My time’s all mixed up at the moment, waiting for the word to go.’

  She noticed that he was edgy, unable to keep still. ‘Still nothing?’

  ‘No, they keep delaying. How about you? We could go out to eat if you like.’

  ‘I had something too. I’ve just been doing some homework.’

  ‘I see that.’ He was twisting his head, looking down at the printouts about Madeleine Smith. ‘Um, 1857? Aren’t you a bit late to solve this one? Ah…’ He looked at the wall. ‘I see you’ve got some more pictures for your network. That’s what I came to give you.’

  He pulled a disk from his pocket and offered it to her. ‘We can load it onto your laptop and set up a generic network for you to play with. You can scan in your images and make different kinds of linkages, groups, whatever you like. You want me to set something up?’

  She didn’t really think she’d use it-she preferred being able to look up at the things on the wall whenever she was passing-but she liked that he wanted to do this for her. She stood behind him, watching, as he sat at the table and played with the machine, and then, when he’d got something working to his satisfaction, she pulled a seat up beside him and followed his instructions. As she got used to the system, she did have to admit that it was neat; however she didn’t have a scanner in the flat, and most of the images weren’t on her computer, so they came to a dead end.

  ‘I’ll get you a scanner,’ he said.

  She laughed. ‘You can’t do that.’

  ‘They’re dirt cheap. Call it a birthday present.’

  ‘Bring me one back from the Gulf,’ she said, ‘and I’ll pay you back.’

  He went over to the images on the wall. ‘But you have some flowers. What are they?’

  ‘Wild flowers from France, apparently, but what they mean, I don’t know.’

  ‘But you’ll find out, eh? Hot on the trail.’ He laughed, a nice warm laugh. It was a long time since she’d heard anyone laughing here, she thought.

  He must have seen the frown on her face, for she suddenly realised he was staring at her. ‘You’re very self-possessed, aren’t you?’ he said.

  ‘Am I? You too, yes?’

  ‘Me? Oh, I don’t know…’ He came over and sat beside her on the sofa. ‘I sometimes feel I don’t know what I am any more.’

  ‘How do you mean?’

  ‘Well, if you’re serious about your job-as you are, as I am-you have to let it shape you, don’t you think? I mean, you may start out with certain qualities and that’s why they pick you, but then the job develops them, exaggerates them, so you can perform. Like, I have to go onto a big project site, where thousands of guys are slaving away, twenty-four hours a day, to meet their deadlines, and I maybe have to go up to this bloody great concrete thing they’ve just finished and say, “No, that’s not good enough, you have to tear it down and do it again.” I know they’re going to argue and try to twist my arm, and I know
I can’t step back, I can’t feel sorry for them, because that’s my job. They think I’m this hard bastard, but I’m not really. It’s just the person I have to be in that situation. Well, hell, it must be the same for you, right?’

  She nodded.

  ‘That wouldn’t be so bad,’ he went on, ‘if it was just like a suit of armour that you could step out of at the end of the day, and be yourself again. But it isn’t like that, is it? It’s become part of you, this other character, you’ve changed to make room for it… Sorry, I’m going on a bit.’

  ‘No, it’s true, what you say. I’m just the same. Right now my boss is telling me to forget about Marion Summers. He thinks I’m getting too involved. I tell myself that he’s wrong, but here I am, sitting in my flat trying to get inside her head. What kind of life is that?’

  ‘Exactly. I think what I’m trying to say is that I sometimes wish I could just have my old self back, because then it would be easier to tell you how good it feels, just sitting here, talking to you.’

  She reached out her hand to his, then leaned forward and kissed him gently on the mouth. Later she led him into her bedroom. The sheets and pillows had been replaced, but she still had a mental image of the cat’s head. She needed him to wipe it away. eighteen

  T hat same evening, Suzanne returned to the bookshop in Notting Hill. She almost hadn’t come-there weren’t convenient trains and the thought of driving up to London for a brief and probably unrewarding talk was unwelcome. But she was intrigued by the thought of seeing Dougie’s wife in the flesh, and in the end she had decided to make the trip. She felt slightly guilty about being in town without telling David, but he might have wanted to come too, and she’d felt obscurely embarrassed by the idea. This was part of her sentimental journey down memory lane, she told herself, probably the end of it, and she avoided asking herself if she hoped Dougie might be there, though surely there was little chance of that.

  But he was there, she saw, as soon as she opened the door and stepped inside. At first she was slightly dazzled by the light, then there he was, standing in a group beside a pyramid of his wife’s books, glass of wine in hand. She recognised him instantly, although when she came to register the details-thinning dark hair slicked back, fleshy jowls, pouchy eyes, heavy build-they were nothing like the teenage Dougie of memory. But those middle-aged features couldn’t hide the dark magnetic eyes, the curling smile of the lips, the interrogating tilt of the head she remembered so vividly. The impact was so immediate and so breathtaking that she actually had to turn away and lean against the end of a bookcase until she had calmed down a little. She didn’t approach him, but handed over her ticket and took a glass of wine, then concentrated on examining the bookshelves furthest from the group until the bookshop manager called for people to take their seats. She sat near the back at the end of an empty row, and focused on a novel she’d picked out, and so didn’t recognise the elderly lady with a stick who came in late, helped by a younger woman. Suzanne looked up and gave an automatic smile which faltered when she saw that it was Joan Warrender, Dougie’s mother, taking the place beside her. LadyWarrender smiled back, then gave a little frown, as if trying to remember why the face was familiar. Then her eyes became sharp. ‘Why, hello again.’